Founder, Agency Appraisal
About Mitchell Caplan
Mitchell brings more than 30 years of experience across agency leadership, marketing transformation and management consulting to his work at Agency Appraisal. On the agency side, he served as CMO at Y&R, McCann and Olson. As a management consultant at KPMG and Flock Associates, he advised marketers at the world’s leading brands on how to structure, run and get the most from their marketing organizations and agency partners.
His work spans every part of the client–agency model: ad agency performance appraisals, agency searches and agency ecosystem design, client and agency team structures, process redesign, and the change management that makes new models stick.
Across every engagement, his approach combines qualitative and quantitative data, resulting in 360° actionable feedback—presented transparently and honestly, guiding essential actions for both the agency and the client.

Career Highlights
KPMG
Managing Director, Marketing Consulting
Flock Associates
Managing Director, U.S.
Olson
Chief Marketing Officer
Young & Rubicam
Chief Marketing Officer, North America
McCann
Chief Marketing Officer
4A’s
Large Agency New Business Committee
Agency Relations Committee
Agency Relations Committee
The Ad Club of New York
Board Member

Speaking
Talks, Panels & Webinars
Mitchell speaks to marketers, finance leaders and agency executives on agency relationships, marketing organization design and the CMO–CFO partnership.
May 2022 · ANA Advertising Financial Management Conference, Orlando
Keys to CFO and CMO Collaboration
June 2023 · ANA Agency Relations Committee
In a Challenging Year, How Do Marketers Balance Between In-House and Agencies?
March 2020 · ANA webinar
How to Optimize Your Agency Relationship vs. an Agency Review
Invite Mitchell to Speak
Looking for a speaker on agency relationships, agency search, marketing organization design or AI in marketing? Get in touch, or read Mitchell’s latest thinking on Substack.
