Building Stronger Marketing Organizations and Higher-Performing Agency Relationships
Independent ad agency appraisals and senior-led consulting that help marketers and their agencies build stronger partnerships, sharper marketing organizations, and better-performing agency relationships.
Our Services
Ad Agency Performance Appraisal & Relationship Assessment
Get an objective, 360° read on how your agency relationships are really performing—and a clear plan to improve them. We surface honest feedback, grounded in facts and data, with no long-term financial commitments, tech, or training needed from you.
Learn MoreAgency Search + Agency Ecosystem Assessment
Seamless and strategic management of selecting and onboarding new agency partners. Clearly defining your needs, selecting the best-fit agency, and setting measurable success criteria ensure you maximize your investment and build a strong, productive relationship. We never ask agencies to pay a fee to participate in a search we manage.
Learn MoreMarketing Operations & Organization Design
Build a marketing organization and agency model designed for how work gets done today—clear structures, faster ways of working, and change that sticks. We evaluate your structure and processes and help you uncover better ways of working.
- Organizational Design (Client and/or Agency Teams)
- Process/Ways of Working Design (Client and/or Agency Teams)
- Change Management
AgencyApprAIse: AI-Powered Self-Service Appraisals
A cost-effective, easy-to-use alternative to traditional appraisal platforms for small and mid-sized agencies and brands. Built on proven consulting techniques and powered by OpenAI—no expensive contracts, no IT headaches. Every license includes a two-hour tutorial with our experts.
Learn More“A 360° review of the client–agency relationship isn’t optional—it’s essential.”
— Heard at the ANA Financial Management Conference

Meet Mitchell Caplan, Founder
Mitchell brings more than 30 years of experience across agency leadership, marketing transformation, and management consulting to his work at Agency Appraisal. On the agency side, he served as CMO at Y&R and McCann. As a management consultant at KPMG and Flock Associates, he advised marketers at the world’s leading brands on how to structure, run, and get the most from their marketing organizations and agency partners.
His work spans every part of the client–agency model: assessing the performance of existing relationships, running agency searches and shaping agency ecosystems, designing client and agency team structures, redesigning processes and ways of working, and leading the change management that makes new models stick.
Across every engagement, his approach combines qualitative and quantitative data, resulting in 360° actionable feedback—presented transparently and honestly, guiding essential actions for both the agency and the client.
Insights From Mitchell Caplan
Mitchell’s perspective on agency performance, marketing transformation and AI.
Read the Latest ArticlesFrequently Asked Questions
What does Agency Appraisal do?
Agency Appraisal is an independent consultancy that helps marketers and their agencies build stronger, higher-performing partnerships. We offer three consulting services—ad agency appraisals (client–agency relationship performance assessments), agency search and agency ecosystem assessment, and marketing operations and organization design—plus AgencyApprAIse, an AI-powered self-service appraisal tool.
What is an ad agency appraisal?
An ad agency appraisal (also called an ad agency performance appraisal or client–agency relationship assessment) is a two-way, 360° review of how a marketer and its advertising agency work together. We combine confidential interviews with quantitative survey data to surface honest, fact-based feedback for both sides, then turn it into clear actions. There are no long-term financial commitments, and no technology or training is needed from you.
Do you appraise media, digital and social agencies?
Yes. We run agency performance appraisals for every type of marketing partner: creative and advertising agencies, media agencies, digital agencies, social media agencies and specialist shops. Each appraisal is tailored to the work that agency does, from media planning and buying to digital, content and social performance, so you get a fair, like-for-like view across your whole agency roster.
When should a brand run an agency search instead of fixing the current relationship?
An assessment often shows whether an existing relationship can be strengthened or whether a new partner is needed. When a search is the right call, we run a right-sized process: clearly defining your needs, selecting the best-fit agency and setting measurable success criteria—without months of process or bloated fees.
Do you charge agencies to take part in an agency search?
No. We never ask agencies to pay a fee to participate in a search we manage, or to join a database of available agencies. We believe that practice is unfair and unethical.
How do you help with marketing organization design?
We evaluate the structure, processes and ways of working of client and agency teams, report on challenges and opportunities, and then support the organizational change—covering organizational design, process and ways-of-working design, and change management.
Who leads Agency Appraisal engagements?
Engagements are led by founder Mitchell Caplan, a former CMO at Y&R and McCann and a management consultant at KPMG and Flock Associates, who has advised marketers at leading brands and their agency partners.
What is AgencyApprAIse?
AgencyApprAIse is a cost-effective, AI-powered tool that lets small and mid-sized brands and agencies run their own agency appraisals. It is built on our consulting methodology and powered by OpenAI; all you need is a ChatGPT account and a license, and every license includes a two-hour tutorial with our experts.
Ready to Strengthen Your Agency Relationships or Marketing Organization?
Let’s talk about where you are today and where you want to go.
Contact Us